Grand Prix Racing Online Forum > Newbie forum > Risks in qualifying. Füge dieses Thema Deiner Blockierliste zu Füge dieses Thema Deinen Favoriten zu
Seite [12 3 » Schneller Sprung auf Seite:
Autor Thema: Risks in qualifying. 64 Antworten
Carlos Carvalho
(Gruppe Amateur - 28)



Einträge: 68
  Land:
Brasilien 
Zertifiziert: 
Alter Eintrag #1 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:01:31 Zitat 
I have a question that has accompanied me since I started playing: risks in qualifying.
We have 04 options: keep the car on the track, push the car a little, push the car a lot and push the car to the limit.
However, what are the factors that infuenciam in deciding the risk to be used? Class ("keep the car on the track" the rookie, "push the car a little" in the amateur etc.)? Car level? Car character? Compatibility between characters of the car and the track at each race? Driver skills (concentration? Talent? Etc.)? Type of tire (more risk with extra-soft, hard with less risk)?
Does anyone have more accurate data and could share?
Thanks, and sorry for the mistakes of translation.
Andi Mankolli
(Gruppe Pro - 14)



Einträge: 1357
  Land:
Albanien 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (2)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #2 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:04:34 Zitat 
It depends on your driver's skills in different situations. :)
Steven Tindle
(Gruppe Rookie - 246)



Einträge: 1886
  Land:
England 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (1)   Gefällt mir nicht (13)
Alter Eintrag #3 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:04:38 Zitat 
In short what you are asking is how will your qualifying time be influenced depending on which risk setting you choose to use? Sorry to be a pain, but I think this one comes under FOBY.
Daniel Bull
(Gruppe Amateur - 50)


Einträge: 251
  Land:
England 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (0)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #4 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:05:13 Zitat 
What Andi said. If you see your driver making very little mistake in practice you know you can probably use a lot of risk in qualifying.
Fernando Manzanares
(Gruppe Master - 3)


Einträge: 346
  Land:
Spanien 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (0)   Gefällt mir nicht (3)
Alter Eintrag #5 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:06:06 Zitat 
I believe it's more or less straightforward, to be honest. You tell your driver how much he should risk, so...
Christoph Seifriedsberger
(Gruppe Master - 4)



Einträge: 6825
  Land:
Österreich 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (4)   Gefällt mir nicht (3)
Alter Eintrag #6 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:10:29 Zitat 
It depends on your driver skills how much risk he can handle. Basically the smaller the driver mistakes are in your practice laps the more risk you can take. One of the important skills for that you named yourself and is quite obvious anyway.

But one thing you need to remember is, that even a driver who is "supposed" to be able to handle higher risks, can do badly once in a while, because it's also luck dependant.
Luiz Menezes
(Gruppe Rookie - 231)



Einträge: 16
  Land:
Brasilien 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (1)   Gefällt mir nicht (9)
Alter Eintrag #7 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:10:31 Zitat 
Quanto mais risco vc corre, maior a probabilidade de o piloto errar. Eu costumo usar push the car a little, mas às vezes tento um risco maior. Aí, às vezes dá certo, e às vezes dá muito errado!
Neil Bontemps
(Gruppe Amateur - 14)


Einträge: 1020
  Land:
England 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (2)   Gefällt mir nicht (41)
Alter Eintrag #8 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:10:38 Zitat 
you been playing this since season 16 and you don't know?????

Wow.....................................................................
Christoph Seifriedsberger
(Gruppe Master - 4)



Einträge: 6825
  Land:
Österreich 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (27)   Gefällt mir nicht (5)
Alter Eintrag #9 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:14:32 Zitat 
Quote ( Neil Bontemps @ June 1st 2012,18:10:38 )

you been playing this since season 16 and you don't know?????

Wow.....................................................................


And this comment was needed because?

If you don't want to add anything useful you better don't post in this thread at all.
Neil Bontemps
(Gruppe Amateur - 14)


Einträge: 1020
  Land:
England 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (4)   Gefällt mir nicht (29)
Alter Eintrag #10 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:16:04 Zitat 
FOBY :P
Serge Girard
(Gruppe Rookie - 333)



Einträge: 1173
  Land:
Kanada 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (6)   Gefällt mir nicht (1)
Alter Eintrag #11 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:16:16 (letzte Änderung Jun 1 2012, 18:21:35 von Serge Girard) Zitat 
Quote ( Neil Bontemps @ June 1st 2012,18:10:38 )

you been playing this since season 16 and you don't know?????

Wow.....................................................................


15 yards penalty for unnecessary roughness

+

match expulsion for unsportmanlike conduct

Carlos, here is a beginning of an answer:

Sion Francis
(Gruppe Pro - 12)


Einträge: 6613
  Land:
Wales 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (11)   Gefällt mir nicht (1)
Alter Eintrag #12 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:25:25 Zitat 
Quote ( Neil Bontemps @ June 1st 2012,18:10:38 )

you been playing this since season 16 and you don't know?????

Wow.....................................................................


I've been playing since season 2 and I don't really know.

Wow........................
Eric Bolder
(Gruppe Pro - 1)


Einträge: 1389
  Land:
Niederlande 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (11)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #13 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 18:37:24 Zitat 
Quote ( Sion Francis @ June 1st 2012,18:25:25 )

I've been playing since season 2 and I don't really know.

Wow........................


Indeed,

And that Bontemps guy 10 season, can't pass amateur

Wow........................
Carlos Carvalho
(Gruppe Amateur - 28)



Einträge: 68
  Land:
Brasilien 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (1)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #14 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 19:36:02 Zitat 
Gentlemen, thank you for the answers.
In fact I play since the 16 season, yet never said I do not know how to use the available risk in qualifying, I said that I still have doubts about factors that may influence in each of the risks, so we can better choose which to use .
I believed for a long time, that the risks were only influenced by the concentration, talent, experience and stamina of the driver. Thus, the pilot can be determined with the use of a risk in all races, observed only the question of weather (sun / rain).
But at times I've seen other players with drivers with skills lower than mine, making absurdly best time in qualifying, anything from 02 to 05 seconds apart. At first I was thinking they were using extra-soft and low fuel, however the race pit strategy was the same as mine, with average, where the soft does not hold out many laps due to temperature etc.. That is, these players made the qualification with the same tires that I, with similar amounts of fuel, had a car like mine, the pilot had worse than my time and did much better.
I realized, too, the difference in results between using a "push the car to the limit" with strategic and extra-soft, medium or hard.
When I speak of difference in the results I'm not talking about the end time of qualification, which of course is different to using extra-soft and hard, but in use compared to other players in the group whose strategy proved to be equal in the race.
I always get setup with final pratice driver mistake less than 0.3 seconds (this is the race today: 0.167s 1:21.668 1:21.835 s s 380 520 620 560 480 435 Extra-soft). It's a driver mistake below, we agree, that would allow me to use "push the car to the limit" in classification of all races. But even using "push the car to the limit" I can not, always, the same performance the qualification that other players with general conditions similar to mine. In some races my result is better, in others worse.
In some races, using a particular strategy, tires and risk, with 02 seconds of difference between Q1 and Q2. In other with the same strategy and tire tracks to be similar, and the same risk I difference Q1 and Q2 of more than 04 seconds.
Then I started to imagine what must have many more factors influencing the choice most appropriate for risk in qualifying at every race. I do not think the ideal is always some risk in every race, only because of the skills of the pilot.
I just suggested this topic that occurred to me some possible factors that might influence, in each race, the most appropriate choice for the risk at that time.
There must be more factors beyond the skills of the pilot.
Fernando Manzanares
(Gruppe Master - 3)


Einträge: 346
  Land:
Spanien 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (1)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #15 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 19:50:55 (letzte Änderung Jun 1 2012, 19:53:18 von Fernando Manzanares) Zitat 
Quote ( Carlos Carvalho @ June 1st 2012,19:36:02 )

I always get setup with final pratice driver mistake less than 0.3 seconds (this is the race today: 0.167s 1:21.668 1:21.835 s s 380 520 620 560 480 435 Extra-soft). It's a driver mistake below, we agree, that would allow me to use "push the car to the limit" in classification of all races.


I disagree with this.

And it's logical that you find some variability in your times from race to race and between qualifying sessions, there's luck involved as well as other factors that make you faster or slower overall, but those other factors are unrelated to the qualifying risks, which are affected by driver skills + luck as has been already said.
Christoph Seifriedsberger
(Gruppe Master - 4)



Einträge: 6825
  Land:
Österreich 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (4)   Gefällt mir nicht (2)
Alter Eintrag #16 geschrieben Jun 1 2012, 19:53:51 Zitat 
As long as not all of your driver mistakes are below 0.1 sec I wouldn't recommend to use "push the car to the limit", but that's only my personal opinion.
It also depends on luck. With a decent driver and pushing the car to the limit, you can get Q1 which is better by up to 1 second in the best case, but it could be also slightly slower than your practice lap in the worst case.

Of course it can vary also a lot in Q2. So with an almost perfect Q1 (compared to your practice times) but a pretty bad Q2, the difference between Q1 and Q2 will be a lot bigger (on the same strategy) as when you have a pretty bad Q1 and a very good Q2. This alone can explain up to 2 seconds difference from race to another (but unlikely to be that much).

What you also need to consider is that there may be different conditions in Q2 (i.e. different temperature). So the temp may suits your tyre better in Q2 which means less difference between Q1 and Q2 or the other way around.
Then it also depends on how accurate your setup conversion is for the different conditions which also adds to that.

Just a few things I could think of right now.
Martin Gelder
(Gruppe Rookie - 88)


Einträge: 42
  Land:
Niederlande 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (0)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #17 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 12:56:50 (letzte Änderung Jun 14 2012, 12:57:53 von Martin Gelder) Zitat 
Does wear % increases if you tell the driver to push the car hard in quali as opposed to telling him to keep the car on the track?
Dylan van den Berg
(Gruppe Amateur - 24)



Einträge: 3575
  Land:
Niederlande 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (0)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #18 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 12:57:54 Zitat 
nope.
Tom Bending
(Gruppe Master - 2)



Einträge: 331
  Land:
England 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (0)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #19 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 13:15:07 Zitat 
Quote ( Martin Gelder @ June 14th 2012,12:56:50 )

Does wear % increases if you tell the driver to push the car hard in quali as opposed to telling him to keep the car on the track?


You can see the wear of the car after each practice lap and each qualifying lap. So this is very easy to answer if you assume it is not added to the wear in the race.
Ganesh Somasundaram
(Gruppe Pro - 9)



Einträge: 592
  Land:
Indien 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (4)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #20 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 13:17:19 (letzte Änderung Jun 14 2012, 13:17:37 von Ganesh Somasundaram) Zitat 
Qualifying does not wear your car, whatever be the risks
Jussi Vasama
(Gruppe Rookie - 235)



Einträge: 306
  Land:
Finnland 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (2)   Gefällt mir nicht (29)
Alter Eintrag #21 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 13:36:33 (letzte Änderung Jun 14 2012, 13:36:56 von Jussi Vasama) Zitat 
Foby :D
Andrei Ciuchi
(Gruppe Amateur - 10)



GPRO Team
Einträge: 21510
  Land:
Kanada 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (12)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #22 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 13:41:40 Zitat 
This is the Newbie forum, Jussi, you can't just say FOBY and leave.
Freddie Higgs
(Gruppe Amateur - 28)



Einträge: 865
  Land:
England 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (0)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #23 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 13:48:05 (letzte Änderung Jun 14 2012, 13:50:35 von Freddie Higgs) Zitat 
Quote ( Andrei Ciuchi @ June 14th 2012,13:41:40 )

you can't just say FOBY and leave.


To be fair if he is going to say that I think I would rather he did just leave

Quote ( Martin Gelder @ June 14th 2012,12:56:50 )

Does wear % increases if you tell the driver to push the car hard in quali as opposed to telling him to keep the car on the track?


well as tom said
Quote ( Tom Bending @ June 14th 2012,13:15:07 )

You can see the wear of the car after each practice lap and each qualifying lap. So this is very easy to answer if you assume it is not added to the wear in the race.


but the answer will be
Quote ( Tom Bending @ June 14th 2012,13:15:07 )

nope.


Edit - even though Dylan said nope Gpro decided by itself that Tom Bending should get the praise
Klaus Erik Kruus
(Gruppe Rookie - 161)


Einträge: 33
  Land:
Estland 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (3)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #24 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 13:55:39 Zitat 
i keep my car on track when my drivers mistakes fourth time is 3,0 -
i use a little risk when my drivers mistakes fourth time is 2,0 - 2,9
i use a lot of risk when my drivers mistakes fourth time is 1,2 - 1,9
i use a maximum risk when my drivers mistakes fourth time is 0,0 - 1,1
Jensen Owens
(Gruppe Rookie - 197)



Einträge: 6400
  Land:
Wales 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (2)   Gefällt mir nicht (4)
Alter Eintrag #25 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 13:58:10 (letzte Änderung Jun 14 2012, 14:03:41 von Jensen Owens) Zitat 
Use your Practice laps look at the times, then in qualifying use push car a little, If its slower than your practice laps then stay on Keep car on track, A couple of races you should find what your driver likes


Neil Bontemps. Is a Legend Great Team mate Team GB
Andrei Ciuchi
(Gruppe Amateur - 10)



GPRO Team
Einträge: 21510
  Land:
Kanada 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (0)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #26 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 14:01:46 (letzte Änderung Jun 14 2012, 14:02:27 von Andrei Ciuchi) Zitat 
Quote ( Klaus Erik Kruus @ June 14th 2012,13:55:39 )

i keep my car on track when my drivers mistakes fourth time is 3,0 -
i use a little risk when my drivers mistakes fourth time is 2,0 - 2,9
i use a lot of risk when my drivers mistakes fourth time is 1,2 - 1,9
i use a maximum risk when my drivers mistakes fourth time is 0,0 - 1,1


I must say I've never seen driver mistake of over 1.5 seconds ... that particular driver skill must be really low.



And by the way, Klaus ... I really wouldn't suggest pushing that hard when the driver makes a mistake that costs him that much time.
Tomek Kiełpiński
(Gruppe Pro - 6)



Einträge: 5682
  Land:
Polen 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (0)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #27 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 14:09:33 Zitat 
Quote ( Klaus Erik Kruus @ June 14th 2012,13:55:39 )

fourth time


Now that's interesting :-) Why fourth?
Henry Ekholm
(Gruppe Rookie - 271)



Einträge: 39
  Land:
Finnland 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (1)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #28 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 14:26:01 (letzte Änderung Jun 14 2012, 14:37:41 von Henry Ekholm) Zitat 
Quote ( Andrei Ciuchi @ June 14th 2012,14:01:46 )

I must say I've never seen driver mistake of over 1.5 seconds ... that particular driver skill must be really low.



Practice laps data (laps done 8/8)
Lap Lap time Driver mistake Net time

*poof*
ok, just big driver mistake in practies lap :)
Q1 time 15/4565 of all rookies at the moment.

Mod Edit: No exact data on the public forum please.
Ed Vermeer
(Gruppe Amateur - 44)


Einträge: 159
  Land:
Niederlande 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (0)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #29 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 19:41:01 Zitat 
Quote ( Sion Francis @ June 1st 2012,18:25:25 )

I've been playing since season 2 and I don't really know.

Wow........................
Quote ( Sion Francis @ June 1st 2012,18:25:25 )

I've been playing since season 2 and I don't really know.

Wow........................


Iám sure you figured that out by now, not really rocket science
Andrei Ciuchi
(Gruppe Amateur - 10)



GPRO Team
Einträge: 21510
  Land:
Kanada 
Zertifiziert: 
Gefällt mir (0)   Gefällt mir nicht (0)
Alter Eintrag #30 geschrieben Jun 14 2012, 20:10:58 Zitat 
Quote ( Ed Vermeer @ June 14th 2012,19:41:01 )

Iám sure you figured that out by now, not really rocket science


I am sure Sion was being sarcastic. :)
Seite [12 3 » Schneller Sprung auf Seite:
Grand Prix Racing Online Forum > Newbie forum > Risks in qualifying. Füge dieses Thema Deiner Blockierliste zu Füge dieses Thema Deinen Favoriten zu

auf dieses Thema antworten