Grand Prix Racing Online Forum > Suggestions forum > Poll for ignore weather change based on remaining laps Bu başlığı engellenenler listesine ekle Bu başlığı takip listesine ekle
Sayfa [1
Forum anket konusu
Ignore weather change is lesw than x laps remaining
Oy kullanmak ya da anket sonuçlarını görntülemek için lütfen Giriş yapın
Yazar Konu: Poll for ignore weather change based on remaining laps 9 Cevaplar
Matthew Dunn
(Grup Amateur - 50)



Gönderiler: 74
  Ülke:
Fransa 
Sertifikalı: 
Bu iletiyi beğendim (4)   Bu iletiyi beğenmedim (2)
Eski Mesaj #1 Yayınlanma zamanı: 22 May 2020, 13:23:30 Alıntı 
This is jist for poll, as my previous post missed the poll

posted today at 13:20:05 Quote
Just like not pitting for technical reasons based on remaining laps it might be nice to be able to do same thing for weather change. So keep the wait x laps before tyre change bit also specify max remaining laps to take weather change into account.

It just adds a little bit more strategic control during race, allowong you to estimate time lost due to being wrong tyres vs extra stop, useful in changeable conditions, when rain stops more than once in a race.
Matthew Dunn
(Grup Amateur - 50)



Gönderiler: 74
  Ülke:
Fransa 
Sertifikalı: 
Bu iletiyi beğendim (0)   Bu iletiyi beğenmedim (1)
Eski Mesaj #2 Yayınlanma zamanı: 22 May 2020, 13:28:56 Alıntı 
Well so far this is extremely popular...
Keith Partridge
(Grup Amateur - 22)



Gönderiler: 1049
  Ülke:
Galler 
Sertifikalı: 
Bu iletiyi beğendim (1)   Bu iletiyi beğenmedim (0)
Eski Mesaj #3 Yayınlanma zamanı: 22 May 2020, 13:32:12 Alıntı 
As I said on your other thread I have been pushing for this for years... as a strategy game it gives an additional important option..... so good luck with it...

But I still would like to hear from those who opposed my suggestion before.... Mainly cos I cannot for the life of me remember the reasons they gave!!!!!
Erik Gaitz
(Grup Pro - 24)



Gönderiler: 484
  Ülke:
Macaristan 
Sertifikalı: 
Bu iletiyi beğendim (4)   Bu iletiyi beğenmedim (0)
Eski Mesaj #4 Yayınlanma zamanı: 22 May 2020, 13:41:37 Alıntı 
Don't refuel due to a weather change should be an option as well
Branislav Mihic
(Grup Master - 4)



Gönderiler: 194
  Ülke:
Danimarka 
Sertifikalı: 
Bu iletiyi beğendim (11)   Bu iletiyi beğenmedim (1)
Eski Mesaj #5 Yayınlanma zamanı: 22 May 2020, 13:53:31 (son değiştirilme 22 May 2020, 13:56:31 kim tarafından: Branislav Mihić) Alıntı 
I am against it. As it is today, you have the option to choose how many laps you want to wait before pitting due to weather change. That is a strategic choice, which in my opinion, also makes sense at the very end of races.
With this suggestion, most of the managers would NOT pit a lap or two or three before the end. So you wouldn't gain anything.

For me, it falls into the same category as having the same tyres in qualifying as in the race. The key is that your strategy sometimes can backfire, and your suggestion wouldn't have any downside to it, so everyone would do the same strategy.
Matthew Dunn
(Grup Amateur - 50)



Gönderiler: 74
  Ülke:
Fransa 
Sertifikalı: 
Bu iletiyi beğendim (1)   Bu iletiyi beğenmedim (1)
Eski Mesaj #6 Yayınlanma zamanı: 22 May 2020, 17:33:28 Alıntı 
Quote ( Branislav Mihic @ May 22nd 2020,13:53:31 )

I am against it. As it is today, you have the option to choose how many laps you want to wait before pitting due to weather change. That is a strategic choice, which in my opinion, also makes sense at the very end of races.
With this suggestion, most of the managers would NOT pit a lap or two or three before the end. So you wouldn't gain anything.

For me, it falls into the same category as having the same tyres in qualifying as in the race. The key is that your strategy sometimes can backfire, and your suggestion wouldn't have any downside to it, so everyone would do the same strategy.


I think picking the number of laps is more complex than jist 2 or 3 everyone does the same., it depends on laptime on lets say wets on a dry track vs the correct dry tyres. This would change based on dry tyre type, driver talent etc, then you need to compare to pit time for the track plus possible refuel, and finally take into account overtaking on the track to decide whether track position is more important
Constantin Heller
(Grup Retired)



Gönderiler: 2462
  Ülke:
Almanya 
Sertifikalı: 
Bu iletiyi beğendim (1)   Bu iletiyi beğenmedim (1)
Eski Mesaj #7 Yayınlanma zamanı: 22 May 2020, 17:41:27 Alıntı 
Quote ( Matthew Dunn @ May 22nd 2020,13:23:30 )

This is jist for poll, as my previous post missed the poll


yes/no polls aren't allowed anyway, I'd guess this post will be deleted, use the other one
Alessandro Casagrande
(Grup Pro - 13)



Gönderiler: 2695
  Ülke:
İtalya 
Sertifikalı: 
Bu iletiyi beğendim (0)   Bu iletiyi beğenmedim (0)
Eski Mesaj #8 Yayınlanma zamanı: 22 May 2020, 17:58:26 Alıntı 
It would be just a basic calculation to decide how many laps on wrong tyres you can do to match the time lost due to the pit stop. I don't see much strategy in it.
Jon Day
(Grup Rookie - 115)


Gönderiler: 10019
  Ülke:
İngiltere 
Sertifikalı: 
Bu iletiyi beğendim (2)   Bu iletiyi beğenmedim (1)
Eski Mesaj #9 Yayınlanma zamanı: 22 May 2020, 18:05:29 Alıntı 
Quote ( Keith Partridge @ May 22nd 2020,13:32:12 )

Mainly cos I cannot for the life of me remember the reasons they gave!!!!!
They said it was shit!

Best wishes as always. Pona xx
Florencia Caro
(Grup Elite)



GPRO Ekibi
Gönderiler: 17157
  Ülke:
Arjantin 
Sertifikalı: 
Bu iletiyi beğendim (0)   Bu iletiyi beğenmedim (0)
Eski Mesaj #10 Yayınlanma zamanı: 22 May 2020, 18:50:20 Alıntı 
Please use the original topic for discussion: /gb/forum/ViewTopic.asp?TopicId=29456#scroll
Sayfa [1
Grand Prix Racing Online Forum > Suggestions forum > Poll for ignore weather change based on remaining laps Bu başlığı engellenenler listesine ekle Bu başlığı takip listesine ekle

Bu başlık moderasyon tarafından kapatılmıştır.